Is Hiring Around the Holidays Ever a Good Idea?

Published:December 6, 2024

The holiday season is often a time of reflection, celebration, and downtime for many businesses. However, for some organizations, it's also a critical period for scaling up, managing increased workloads, or filling key roles. As the year winds down, business owners may wonder: Should I consider hiring around the holidays? While the holiday season can present unique challenges when it comes to recruitment, it can also offer distinct advantages. In this blog, we explore the pros and cons of holiday hiring and offer tips for making the most of seasonal recruitment efforts.

Challenges of Hiring During the Holiday Season

Hiring around the holidays presents a distinct set of challenges. During the holiday season, both candidates and hiring teams face distractions, scheduling conflicts, and competing priorities. On the other hand, holiday hiring can also offer opportunities for businesses looking to take advantage of a less crowded job market, access fresh talent, and position themselves for success in the new year. As we explore both sides of the equation, it is important to weigh the timing, your business needs, and your ability to onboard and integrate new employees during this busy season. Let’s dive deeper into the pros and cons of holiday season hiring.

Pros of Hiring Around the Holidays

Availability of Talent: One of the key advantages of holiday season hiring is the availability of talent. Many professionals take time off during the holidays, which can leave certain roles unfilled or may create gaps in teams. By hiring during this period, you may have access to high-quality candidates who are actively looking for opportunities—whether they are recent graduates, individuals seeking new opportunities, or experienced workers who are eager to start fresh in the new year.
Reduced Competition: While many companies may put hiring efforts on hold during the holiday season, fewer job postings mean less competition for top talent. This can give your business a competitive edge in attracting skilled candidates who might otherwise be swayed by a more aggressive job market. Job seekers, especially those eager to start a new role in the new year, may be more motivated to engage with your company’s hiring process if you are one of the few actively recruiting.
Motivation to Start Fresh: The holiday season often marks a time of new beginnings, and many professionals use this period to reflect on their careers and seek new challenges. Candidates who are actively applying for jobs during the holidays are often highly motivated and ready for a fresh start – January and February are in fact the most common months employees seek out a new career. As a result, they may bring a higher level of energy, commitment, and focus to their job search and, eventually, to their role within your company.

Cons of Hiring Around the Holidays

Potential Distractions: The holiday season is a time filled with personal and family commitments, travel, and holiday festivities. Many job seekers may be less focused on the application process or less available for interviews due to these distractions. Similarly, hiring managers and HR teams may also be balancing end-of-year responsibilities and taking vacations, making it more challenging to coordinate interviews and decision-making.
Limited Time for Onboarding: Onboarding new hires is a critical process for ensuring their success within your organization, and the holidays may not provide the ideal environment for effective onboarding. With employees taking time off and other distractions in the workplace, it can be difficult to provide the necessary support, training, and integration that new hires need to succeed. If your company doesn’t have a robust onboarding process in place, the holiday season might not be the best time to bring on new employees.
Holiday Burnout: The end of the year can be exhausting for both employees and employers, especially in industries with heavy workloads leading into the holiday season. Holiday burnout can result in lower productivity, increased stress, and a lack of focus. Introducing new hires during this time may make it harder for them to settle in and fully engage in their work, especially if they’re overwhelmed by the hustle and bustle of the season. Additionally, existing team members may already be stretched thin and unable to dedicate the time needed to onboard new staff effectively.

Best Practices for Holiday Hiring

While there are certainly challenges to hiring around the holidays, there are strategies you can employ to make the process more effective:

Plan Ahead: If you know your business experiences higher demand during the holiday season, start the hiring process well in advance. Use the fall months to recruit candidates and schedule interviews ahead of time, so you can bring on new team members before the chaos of the holidays begins.
Streamline the Process: Simplify your hiring process by using online tools for interviews and assessments. Virtual interviews can help reduce scheduling conflicts and allow candidates to interview from the comfort of their homes, which is especially useful during the busy holiday season.
Be Flexible: While it’s important to stay efficient, flexibility can go a long way. Consider offering flexible start dates or temporary contracts to candidates who may be looking for seasonal work, or for those who may not be able to start immediately due to holiday commitments.
Provide Strong Onboarding Support: Even during the holiday season, an effective onboarding experience is essential. If possible, assign a dedicated onboarding coordinator who can ensure new hires receive the attention and guidance they need to integrate smoothly into the company.
Communicate Clearly: Be transparent about the timing of interviews, the hiring process, and expectations for new hires. Ensure candidates know that the holiday season might cause some delays, but that you are committed to a timely and smooth process.

Get HR Help for Holiday Season Hiring

Hiring during the holiday season comes with both risks and rewards. The availability of motivated talent and reduced competition can present valuable opportunities for companies that are prepared to navigate the challenges of holiday distractions, limited onboarding time, and potential burnout.

For businesses with immediate staffing needs or those looking to tap into a fresh talent pool, holiday hiring can be a great option. However, it’s important to remain mindful of potential challenges and ensure that your hiring process and onboarding strategy are tailored to the season.

Take a strategic approach to holiday hiring by scheduling a free consultation call with Humani HR today to find out how we can help!

Carly Holm

CEO & Founder of Humani HR

Carly Holm is the CEO and Founder of Humani HR. She has spent 15 years in the HR realm, and in 2022, she was awarded the Forty Under 40 Award for Canada’s National Capital Region. You can find Carly on LinkedIn.

recruitment

What Our Clients Say

“Humani has been instrumental in guiding us as we built our people organization. They are some of the most wonderful people to work with, highly recommended for anyone who may consider needing help navigating the tricky world of people management in this modern age.”

Mantaro Capital Corp. (Vancouver, BC)

more testimonials

free consultation

Challenges of Hiring During the Holiday Season

Pros of Hiring Around the Holidays

Availability of Talent: One of the key advantages of holiday season hiring is the availability of talent. Many professionals take time off during the holidays, which can leave certain roles unfilled or may create gaps in teams. By hiring during this period, you may have access to high-quality candidates who are actively looking for opportunities—whether they are recent graduates, individuals seeking new opportunities, or experienced workers who are eager to start fresh in the new year.

Reduced Competition: While many companies may put hiring efforts on hold during the holiday season, fewer job postings mean less competition for top talent. This can give your business a competitive edge in attracting skilled candidates who might otherwise be swayed by a more aggressive job market. Job seekers, especially those eager to start a new role in the new year, may be more motivated to engage with your company’s hiring process if you are one of the few actively recruiting.

Motivation to Start Fresh: The holiday season often marks a time of new beginnings, and many professionals use this period to reflect on their careers and seek new challenges. Candidates who are actively applying for jobs during the holidays are often highly motivated and ready for a fresh start – January and February are in fact the most common months employees seek out a new career. As a result, they may bring a higher level of energy, commitment, and focus to their job search and, eventually, to their role within your company.

Cons of Hiring Around the Holidays

Potential Distractions: The holiday season is a time filled with personal and family commitments, travel, and holiday festivities. Many job seekers may be less focused on the application process or less available for interviews due to these distractions. Similarly, hiring managers and HR teams may also be balancing end-of-year responsibilities and taking vacations, making it more challenging to coordinate interviews and decision-making.

Limited Time for Onboarding: Onboarding new hires is a critical process for ensuring their success within your organization, and the holidays may not provide the ideal environment for effective onboarding. With employees taking time off and other distractions in the workplace, it can be difficult to provide the necessary support, training, and integration that new hires need to succeed. If your company doesn’t have a robust onboarding process in place, the holiday season might not be the best time to bring on new employees.

Holiday Burnout: The end of the year can be exhausting for both employees and employers, especially in industries with heavy workloads leading into the holiday season. Holiday burnout can result in lower productivity, increased stress, and a lack of focus. Introducing new hires during this time may make it harder for them to settle in and fully engage in their work, especially if they’re overwhelmed by the hustle and bustle of the season. Additionally, existing team members may already be stretched thin and unable to dedicate the time needed to onboard new staff effectively.

Best Practices for Holiday Hiring

While there are certainly challenges to hiring around the holidays, there are strategies you can employ to make the process more effective:

Plan Ahead: If you know your business experiences higher demand during the holiday season, start the hiring process well in advance. Use the fall months to recruit candidates and schedule interviews ahead of time, so you can bring on new team members before the chaos of the holidays begins.

Streamline the Process: Simplify your hiring process by using online tools for interviews and assessments. Virtual interviews can help reduce scheduling conflicts and allow candidates to interview from the comfort of their homes, which is especially useful during the busy holiday season.

Be Flexible: While it’s important to stay efficient, flexibility can go a long way. Consider offering flexible start dates or temporary contracts to candidates who may be looking for seasonal work, or for those who may not be able to start immediately due to holiday commitments.

Provide Strong Onboarding Support: Even during the holiday season, an effective onboarding experience is essential. If possible, assign a dedicated onboarding coordinator who can ensure new hires receive the attention and guidance they need to integrate smoothly into the company.

Communicate Clearly: Be transparent about the timing of interviews, the hiring process, and expectations for new hires. Ensure candidates know that the holiday season might cause some delays, but that you are committed to a timely and smooth process.